Are Over-Award Payments Enough?


20 Feb, 2017

“But I am paying over award rates. Isn’t that enough?”

Most business owners who get into trouble with Industrial Tribunals all say this line. They think that by paying a little (or a lot) over the award, that they can ignore the rest of the clauses in the relevant industrial award. And that’s where they come unstuck!

Why Pay Over Award Rates?

Businesses pay over award rates for many reasons. The main reason is to attract and retain quality employees.  Unless they meet the market, their staff may look elsewhere, creating turnover problems in their organisation.

Another reason that a business may pay over-award is to simplify their payroll administration by rolling up a number of entitlements such as leave loading, regular rostered overtime and meal allowances into a flat over award rate.

A Few Key Things to Know About Paying Over Award

If you are thinking of paying an employee over the award, you need to dot your eyes and cross your t’s.

This is a hotly litigated area of industrial law, and it is an area where we recommend you seek competent legal advice to ensure you are not leaving yourself open to challenge down the track.

Unless you have specifically entered into an Individual Flexibility Arrangement (IFA), or unless the person is over the high-income threshold, or unless you are covered by an approved enterprise agreement, or unless you have entered into an annualised agreement with the person under the relevant clause in their award, then even if you pay over award wages, ALL the remainder of the award conditions apply.

If your agreement is not clear, it can lead to conflict over whether something has been paid; whether someone has been paid enough; conflict over payments on sick leave or annual leave; and conflict on termination about termination or redundancy payments.

If you fail to correctly comply with award provisions, then you can be taken before the relevant tribunals and face significant fines as well as the requirement to repay entitlements. Remember, underpaid employees can seek redress for up to 6 years.

In other words, if you want to pay over the award, and roll up other conditions into that payment, then a handshake or a simple letter is generally not enough to reduce your risk.

If You Are Considering Over Award Payments

The simplest option is to simply pay higher than award rates and then apply all remaining terms and conditions as per the award.

If you want to head down the path of paying over the award AND roll up a number of terms and conditions into the rate, you need to clearly document what has been rolled up into the wage.

You also need to establish a regular review of the arrangement (the end of the financial year as part of your payroll processes is ideal), to ensure that the person remains “better off overall” through the term of the agreement.

Unless the level of over-award payment is equal to, or greater, than the amount the employee would have received had the entitlements been calculated on the appropriate award rate classification, you will be in breach of the Fair Work Act and can be penalised.

Finally, you need to reach agreement on wage adjustments if the award rate changes. Will you increase the over award rate in line with the award changes, or will you absorb the award increase into the over award rate and maintain the rate?

Paying over the award is not a simple solution to staffing issues. If you want to pay your employees over the award by rolling up conditions, seek advice first.


Instant HR Policies & Procedures Manual

Need help with your HR?

The Instant HR Policies and Procedures Manual saves weeks of work in creating compliant human resources policies for your team.

Ingrid: Lead Author, Australian Employee Manual

HR Author and Lecturer with over 25 years' experience in human resources and workplace relations in Australia. Lead Author of Instant HR Policies & Procedures, NDIS Direct Employment HR Manual, and Employee Performance Reviews: Tips, Templates and Tactics.

About Us

We are an Australian human resources business specialising in small businesses and not for profits, based in Brisbane, Australia.


If you are an Employee and need HR Advice, call Fair Work Australia 13 13 94



Our Most Popular HR Product

Recent Posts

Related Posts

Minimum Wage Increased by 5.2%

Minimum Wage Increased by 5.2%

The Fair Work Commission has ruled that the National Minimum Wage will increase by 5.2% to $21.38 per hour. This represents an increase of $40 per week. They also ruled that modern award minimum rates will increase by 4.6%, subject to a minimum increase of $40 per...

read more
Updates to Our Employee Manual Products Released

Updates to Our Employee Manual Products Released

We have just released a series of updates to our Instant HR Policies and Procedures Manual, New Employee Inductions, NDIS Self Managers Direct Employment HR Manual and the NDIS Support Worker Agency HR Manual. Clients with current subscriptions to these products are...

read more
Minimum Wage Increased by 2.5%

Minimum Wage Increased by 2.5%

The Fair Work Commission handed down its annual minimum wage review on 16th June 2021. They ordered an increase of 2.5% on the minimum wage, increasing it to $20.33 per hour or $772.60 per week. While the increase will apply to most awards from 1st July 2021, some of...

read more